The Ontario Chief Coroner’s Office is now involved in the troubling case of a stillborn baby whose body was lost by Etobicoke General Hospital nearly three years ago. The case, which has left the baby’s grieving mother in emotional turmoil, highlights significant failures in hospital procedures and raises serious questions about accountability.
The Tragic Loss
In the fall of 2021, Rachel Osbourn-Hutchinson gave birth to a stillborn daughter, Iah, at Etobicoke General Hospital. The devastating loss was compounded by what followed in the months after the birth—especially after the hospital failed to properly handle the baby’s remains.
Initially, Osbourn-Hutchinson agreed to an autopsy on her daughter, which was expected to be carried out at the Hospital for Sick Children in Toronto. However, six months later, Osbourn-Hutchinson was informed that her baby’s body had never reached the facility for the procedure. The mother was devastated by the news. “I was just devastated. My mind started going to the worst-case scenario—that my baby was out there in the cold, unprotected, by herself,” Osbourn-Hutchinson shared in an interview with CityNews.
When Osbourn-Hutchinson inquired about the whereabouts of her daughter’s body, she was met with the shocking response that hospital staff were also unaware of its location. “I haven’t been able to say goodbye to her properly, it’s this lingering thing that weighs on my chest. I’m anxious all the time. This is an open wound I’m walking around with,” she said.
The Long Wait and Unexpected Discovery
The saga of uncertainty dragged on for almost two years, until July 2023, when Osbourn-Hutchinson received a phone call from an Etobicoke General employee. The caller informed her that they had located her daughter’s body—and that it had been at the hospital the entire time. This revelation only deepened the emotional trauma for the grieving mother, who had spent nearly two years without knowing the fate of her baby.
Despite the discovery, Osbourn-Hutchinson refused to accept the body until a DNA test could confirm that it was indeed her daughter. However, she says the hospital was uncooperative. At one point, she claims, hospital staff issued an ultimatum that they would begin the disposal process of the remains unless she took immediate action. This distressing development left Osbourn-Hutchinson with a sense of helplessness and growing frustration.
Legal Intervention and Coroner’s Involvement
In response to the ongoing uncertainty and lack of closure, Osbourn-Hutchinson hired lawyer Kathryn Marshall to help navigate the complex situation. Marshall confirmed that the Office of the Chief Coroner has now intervened in the case. The coroner will conduct a DNA test to verify whether the remains found at Etobicoke General belong to Osbourn-Hutchinson’s daughter, Iah.
“We want to know if this is her baby,” Marshall said, expressing the family’s hope for some form of closure. The involvement of the Chief Coroner marks a critical development in the case, as the investigation now enters a forensic phase aimed at determining the identity of the remains and addressing the failures in the hospital’s handling of the situation.
Health Minister’s Response and Lack of Formal Investigation
Ontario’s Minister of Health, Sylvia Jones, responded to the situation by stating that, at this point, no further investigation into the hospital’s actions would be launched. According to Jones, the ministry has reviewed the relevant policies and believes that the responsibility of all parties involved is clear. She further stated, “At this point, I do not believe [an investigation] is necessary, [but] we will watch and ensure this family gets the appropriate resolution.”
However, Marshall, the family’s lawyer, was highly critical of the Minister’s stance. “Something went wrong here. There were probably multiple wrongs over the course of several years. This is something the Ministry of Health should look into,” Marshall argued. She dismissed the Ministry’s response as a “cop-out,” adding that the failures at the hospital deserve a much more thorough investigation.
Additionally, Marshall pointed out that the hospital has yet to issue a formal apology to Osbourn-Hutchinson for the distress caused by the loss and mishandling of her daughter’s remains. This lack of accountability has only deepened the emotional scars for the family.
A Mother’s Pain: A Search for Closure
For Osbourn-Hutchinson, the emotional toll of the situation has been overwhelming. The inability to say goodbye to her daughter in a meaningful way has left a profound impact. The years of uncertainty, compounded by the hospital’s failure to provide clarity, have been a constant source of anguish. “It’s like a lingering thing that weighs on my chest,” she said, describing the ongoing pain she has lived with since Iah’s birth.
Despite the heartache, Osbourn-Hutchinson is relieved that the Chief Coroner’s office has now taken charge of the situation. The involvement of the coroner has provided some hope that the family may finally receive answers. “I just want to know if it’s her,” Osbourn-Hutchinson said, emphasizing her desire to give her daughter a proper burial and the closure she desperately needs.
The mother expressed that her greatest hope is that she and her husband can finally “lay their sweet baby to rest.” After years of emotional turmoil, the family now faces the difficult task of reconciling their grief with the unresolved nature of their loss.
Broader Implications: Hospital Accountability and Patient Trust
The case has raised serious concerns about the handling of deceased patients in hospitals, especially in cases involving stillbirths and autopsies. The incident at Etobicoke General Hospital calls into question the effectiveness of the hospital’s protocols for managing sensitive situations involving deceased patients. The failure to properly handle Iah’s remains has led to a complete breakdown in trust between the hospital and the family, with broader implications for patient care and hospital accountability.
While the Ministry of Health has maintained that an investigation is unnecessary, the public outcry over the handling of the situation may prompt further scrutiny of the hospital’s policies and procedures. Medical professionals and institutions are expected to demonstrate the highest level of care and responsibility, particularly in cases involving families who are already experiencing profound loss. The Osbourn-Hutchinson family’s experience has brought attention to the vulnerabilities in the system that must be addressed to prevent such incidents from happening in the future.
Looking Ahead: A Quest for Justice
As the Chief Coroner’s Office begins its investigation, the Osbourn-Hutchinson family is cautiously hopeful that they will finally receive answers regarding the fate of their daughter. The DNA test and forensic investigation will hopefully provide clarity about whether the remains found at Etobicoke General are indeed Iah’s and, ultimately, allow the family to give their baby the dignified farewell she deserves.
For Osbourn-Hutchinson and her husband, the fight for closure is far from over. However, the involvement of the coroner marks an important step in their journey toward justice and healing. It is now up to the legal and medical authorities to ensure that the truth comes to light and that the hospital is held accountable for its failures.
The case also serves as a powerful reminder of the importance of transparency, accountability, and compassion in healthcare settings—particularly in cases where families are already navigating the heartbreaking grief of losing a child. Only through a thorough investigation and appropriate actions can such tragedies be prevented in the future.
Related topics:
